Okay, the girl from the book, she's giving HORRIBLE reasons why she killed herself so far. Wah wah wah You were nice to be but then I realized you were nice to everybody so I'm going to kill myself wah wah wah
Okay first of all--these would be good only if they stated the whole story. They just sound dumb because its like the last half and that's it. I mean why WOULDN'T you put the whole story? it's not even like any of them are that long..it doesn't even make sense because it has the second part but not the first part but it talks about the second part so no one knows what you're talking about. like Marcus's tape. It says "doesn't that sound familiar? isn't that how i convinced myself not to take my survey out of the box?" or something like that--and she didn't even explain about the surveys. these are kind of dumb if you ask me.
and yes, I have read the book, and I completely agree that her first 8 reasons or so makes her look like a sissy. those things happen to everyone--she could have sucked it up and stopped whining. The real reasons, that make you feel bad for her instead of make fun of her, are the last few. she still does seem a little like shes having a pitty party.
don't get me wrong I loved the book, and it was really good, and I actually cried at some parts, but if you think about it, it is kind of ridiculous sometimes.
I totally agree. These tapes make it sound like she's looking for reasons, when in the book, her reasons are tragic. If I were her, I would have done the same thing.
I love how they make it sound like Marcus is on here for almost standing her up.
They also make it sound like her 'reputation' is in her head.
For those of you who didn't read the book.. he moved her to a booth.. and started to put his hand up her leg. She told him to stop and he wouldn't.. she had to literally shove him out of the booth to get him to stop touching her.
I didn't just mean these tapes. I mean..even in the book--her first 8 reasons are somewhat stupid. everyone gets a reputation, they just have to learn how to deal with it. She should have sucked it up.
Obviously she should have dealt with it better. Anyone who commits suicide should have dealt with things in a better way. The book is her side of the story though and she wouldn't need to suck it up if they didn't treat her that way.
Oh, so let's blame the victim. You have no idea what those things are like, and you don't know what it's like to have to deal with guys trying to molest you clearly.
I kind of agree about the first few reasons. They're not the biggest reasons ever for killing yourself. But the thing is, Hannah even admits towards the end that she is putting the blame on other people. When it comes down to it, the only one she should blame is herself. But it's her side of the story - of course she would have excuses why it's not her fault. It's what most people would do.
almost all suicides seem avoidable to the outstanders that does not suffer from the illness.. ILLNESS.. depression makes one see the world in a shade of colour.. normal healthy people tend not to understand why one with depression may take things more personal.. or get offended much more easily.. being paranoid and uber sensitive towards other people's actions is only one of the many signs that someone is suffering from depression.. xxx
Depression is not something you can just "suck up" and get over. You may have all been 'touched' by the book but it's pretty clear that none of you have ever been depressed. If you would, you'd know how shattering it is every time you hear someone say that people just need to get over it.
I agree with the above commentrr! u cant just suck up depression, its very hard to convince yourself that there is something worth living for when ur feeling so weighted with emotions.
29 comments:
First!
these tapes are just, wow.
i check everyday for a new tape.
It's unbelievable what can affect certain people.
It scares me sometimes
These tapes make me think about what to say next...
There's only a couple people who would possibly be putting these up for everyone to see.
I think I know who it is.
well so who do u think it is? i check this site every thirty mins for a new tape. i'm actually rereading the book right now!
So far her reasons for killing herself aren't very good.
Its a book? I'm so confused..
Yes, it's just a book. It's not based on a true story. The book is called "Thirteen Reasons Why" by Jay Asher.
dayum this DEFF is gunna make meh think twice b4 i do suttin =|
i neva rlly realized how much our actionz can affect other ppl
If this is supposed to be someone in the book then I think it's Tony.
Totally! Those are the hands of a mechanic!
what the hell is this shit...is this real? it's tripping me the hell out...
wait, this isn't based on a true story?
check out Thirteen Reasons Why by Jay Asher
Okay, the girl from the book, she's giving HORRIBLE reasons why she killed herself so far.
Wah wah wah You were nice to be but then I realized you were nice to everybody so I'm going to kill myself wah wah wah
You're an idiot. Did you even read the book? Clearly not. How about you get the full story before going online and posting hate mail.
The tapes posted here are about 5% of the ACTUAL tapes from the book.
Okay first of all--these would be good only if they stated the whole story. They just sound dumb because its like the last half and that's it. I mean why WOULDN'T you put the whole story? it's not even like any of them are that long..it doesn't even make sense because it has the second part but not the first part but it talks about the second part so no one knows what you're talking about. like Marcus's tape. It says "doesn't that sound familiar? isn't that how i convinced myself not to take my survey out of the box?" or something like that--and she didn't even explain about the surveys. these are kind of dumb if you ask me.
and yes, I have read the book, and I completely agree that her first 8 reasons or so makes her look like a sissy. those things happen to everyone--she could have sucked it up and stopped whining. The real reasons, that make you feel bad for her instead of make fun of her, are the last few. she still does seem a little like shes having a pitty party.
don't get me wrong I loved the book, and it was really good, and I actually cried at some parts, but if you think about it, it is kind of ridiculous sometimes.
I totally agree. These tapes make it sound like she's looking for reasons, when in the book, her reasons are tragic. If I were her, I would have done the same thing.
I love how they make it sound like Marcus is on here for almost standing her up.
They also make it sound like her 'reputation' is in her head.
For those of you who didn't read the book.. he moved her to a booth.. and started to put his hand up her leg. She told him to stop and he wouldn't.. she had to literally shove him out of the booth to get him to stop touching her.
I didn't just mean these tapes. I mean..even in the book--her first 8 reasons are somewhat stupid. everyone gets a reputation, they just have to learn how to deal with it. She should have sucked it up.
Obviously she should have dealt with it better. Anyone who commits suicide should have dealt with things in a better way.
The book is her side of the story though and she wouldn't need to suck it up if they didn't treat her that way.
Oh, so let's blame the victim. You have no idea what those things are like, and you don't know what it's like to have to deal with guys trying to molest you clearly.
This audio starts on p. 93 of the book
I kind of agree about the first few reasons. They're not the biggest reasons ever for killing yourself. But the thing is, Hannah even admits towards the end that she is putting the blame on other people. When it comes down to it, the only one she should blame is herself. But it's her side of the story - of course she would have excuses why it's not her fault. It's what most people would do.
almost all suicides seem avoidable to the outstanders that does not suffer from the illness.. ILLNESS.. depression makes one see the world in a shade of colour.. normal healthy people tend not to understand why one with depression may take things more personal.. or get offended much more easily.. being paranoid and uber sensitive towards other people's actions is only one of the many signs that someone is suffering from depression.. xxx
Anyone who commits suicide is completly lost...
Nadia that is soo true!
I think if Tony was the one who put the tapes up, then someone later on didn't pass on the tapes.
Depression is not something you can just "suck up" and get over. You may have all been 'touched' by the book but it's pretty clear that none of you have ever been depressed. If you would, you'd know how shattering it is every time you hear someone say that people just need to get over it.
I agree with the above commentrr! u cant just suck up depression, its very hard to convince yourself that there is something worth living for when ur feeling so weighted with emotions.
Post a Comment